Abstract
Introduction
In the UK, concerns regarding the safe use of bedrails, especially in nursing homes and a person’s own home, prompted a National Patient Safety Alert in August 2023. A scoping review was conducted to identify and map the literature relating to bedrail use in hospital and community settings and identify future areas of research.
Methods
The scoping review was performed in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. The search was conducted using MEDLINE, EMBASE, EMCARE, COCHRANE, BASE, CINAHL, and Google Scholar. Two reviewers independently contributed to screening. Data extraction included reason and prevalence of use, causes of harm and alternatives to bedrails. Findings were reported narratively.
Results
A total of 33 papers were included. Bedrails were widely used across hospital settings and nursing homes. No studies examined bed rail use in a person’s own home. Bed rails were primarily prescribed as a falls prevention device, despite the absence of empirical evidence supporting their effectiveness. In the UK, bedrail use appeared to be influenced by local culture and practice rather than policy. Self-reported use of bedrails as patient restraints in the UK, perhaps indicates inadequate legal literacy among equipment prescribers. Bedrails were found to be safe when used appropriately. There is concern that bedrail use is increasing with increasing patient dependency and advances in bed technology but authors express apprehension that it may be ethically impossible to design a randomised controlled trial to address patient safety concerns.
Conclusion
Empirical data supporting bedrails as a falls prevention device are lacking. Additionally, there is a dearth of evidence reporting the opinions of users or inquiries regarding bedrails in a person’s own home. Therefore, clinicians are advised to consider bedrail prescriptions with a sense of responsibility and inquisitive inquiry to support both ethical and lawful use.